Beetle in a box

I spent the weekend before last with my brother Adrian at his home in Bath, which is the longest period of time we’ve spent together for donkey’s years and was really lovely. I then caught a bus which travelled through the former mining areas of Somerset around Radstock and Midsomer Norton, before going through the Mendips, with Glastonbury Tor on the horizon, and descending to Wells, the (self-proclaimed) smallest city in England. Wells has a lovely centre – mainly but not only the beautiful Gothic cathedral and the adjoining, fully-moated Bishop’s Palace.

Wells Cathedral by day
Wells Cathedral at night
Bishop’s Palace, Wells

I got there early enough to go round and inside the cathedral, and then, up the High Street, to see a photo of my then-bearded mug on a small poster in the window of the King’s Head. Just as well I’d shaved the beard off at the start of this year, otherwise there would have been mayhem: a posse of citizens out to lasso the wanted man.

Wanted!

Ama Bolton and her group of like-minded folk, the Fountain Poets, were very welcoming, and read – and, in Rachael Clyne’s case, sang – some fine pieces. I read from both my collections plus a couple of new poems too. Ama has kindly invited me back for another reading next March, so I’d better write lots more poems in the next 11 and a half months. I must add the not-quite-random fact that both Ama and I have had poems published about dental hygienists!

Much of my reading has again been for reviews, and, for once, of books which I enjoyed and admired without exception. Among the books I’ve read solely (or mainly) for pleasure are Dean Browne’s After Party (Picador, 2025), this month’s Poetry Book Club choice, and Ted Kooser’s Winter Morning Walks: one hundred postcards to Jim Harrison (Carnegie Mellon University Press, 2000). Two more different books you’d be hard-pressed to find, yet I like them both: the inventive verbal fireworks of Browne’s poems contrast sharply with Kooser’s quiet, weather- and nature-based short poems. In a preface, Kooser says he write the poems ‘during [his] recovery from surgery and radiation for cancer’, with a two-mile walk every dawn because he’d ‘been told by [his] radiation oncologist to stay out of the sun for a year because of skin sensitivity’. Even without that background information, Kooser’s poems would still have been very moving. I hope he won’t mind me quoting this one in full:

March 10

          Quiet and cold at 6 a.m.


At dawn in the roadside churchyard,
the recent, polished headstones glance and flash
as if the newly dead were waving pink placards
protesting the loss of their influence.
But the soft old marbles, grainy from weather
and losing their names, have a steady glow,
like paper bags with candles lit inside,
lining a path, an invitation.


Earlier this year, I started getting a bit of pain in my right shoulder, but I thought little of it. It’s considerably worsened since then, with constant pain down my right arm and in my neck, to the point that each ordinarily simple task is a bit of an ordeal. After an x-ray a fortnight ago and appointments with a doctor and a physio this week, it seems that the top of my spine is the most likely source of the problem and that it’s all related to my nervous system – ‘my noives’, as Oliver Hardy would say. I might know more after blood tests on Sunday and more physio on Monday.

In #293 (et al)) of his Philosophical Investigations, Wittgenstein considers what we mean when we each, individually, talk about ‘pain’, and compares it thus;

Suppose everyone had a box with something in it: we call it a “beetle”. No one can look into anyone else’s box, and everyone says he knows what a beetle s only by looking at his beetle.—Here it would be quite possible for everyone to have something different in his box. One might even imagine such a thing constantly changing. [Etc.]

I like to imagine the beetle in my box is a shiny, metallic green. I think I have a fairly high tolerance for pain (for a man), but this is testing my patience to the limit. I’m also struggling to do things one-handed, and with the ‘wrong’ hand at that, and with not being able to run. I walk much slower too. These are intensely annoying things, but I realise many people live with much worse conditions. Dean Browne, via a character, defined pain as something else, in the opening of his poem ‘Quiche’, available here.


Responses

  1. Clare Pooley Avatar
    Clare Pooley

    I am pleased the reading went well and thank you for including the photos of Wells and your wanted poster! I also enjoyed reading the poems you chose to highlight.

    I hope between you and the specialists you can find some relief for your pain. I do like Wittgenstein’s beetle idea! I can empathise with you as I have had chronic pain for many years. Most of the time it is under control but now and again it decides to make itself felt and it reminds me of how it was at the beginning before I got the help. Best of luck.

    1. Matthew Paul Avatar
      Matthew Paul

      Thanks, Clare. I’m very sorry to hear you’ve had chronic pain for years, but I’m glad it did get controlled.

  2. quercuscommunity Avatar
    quercuscommunity

    I always hate it when they ask me to rate my pain on a scale of 1-10. How do I know? I used to do an annual pain survey for a University study – they gave me a list of words and asked which applied. There were some very strange words. I really should find a copy and use it as the basis for a poem. The beetle image is great, I have worried all my life that what I think of is not what other people think of – the colour blue for instance, but I have never managed to explain it o neatly.

    1. Matthew Paul Avatar
      Matthew Paul

      Yes, it’s so hard, isn’t it? I described the pain I get in my shoulder-blade as being like chronic indigestion, but that’s still not really right. Re the broader question of colours, etc., GE Moore likened happiness to yellowness, as both being simple perceptions, but Wittgenstein in Philosophical Investigations was rather more sceptical and analytical about what it is for someone else to understand what an individual is talking and thinking about, pointing at, etc. I find reading him every now and then to be rewarding – as I’ve done for 40 years now, since reading it as part of my degree.

      1. quercuscommunity Avatar
        quercuscommunity

        And there you have me! Wittgenstein didn’t form a great part of my City & Guilds (Poultry Production) course, which is why my writer’s bio generally tails off with the words ” . . . and wishes he’d worked harder at school.”

        I will make a point of making this my next field of study, because the subject, as I say, has long been something that has interested me.

      2. Matthew Paul Avatar
        Matthew Paul

        Qualifications aren’t everything. Most of the books I read while I was at university were poetry and novels, not the philosophy I was supposed to be reading!

      3. quercuscommunity Avatar
        quercuscommunity

        A recent edition of Philosophy Now (Issue 158: October/November 2023), suggests that philosophy can be defined as “acts of communicating one’s experience of the world in a way that others can recognize and identify with.” This sounds like poetry to me.

        It also shows why I should not be allowed to look things up on the internet. 🙂

      4. Matthew Paul Avatar
        Matthew Paul

        Yes, that does sound more like a definition of poetry than philosophy – though, for me, the writings of some philosophers, Wittgenstein especially, accidentally verge on poetry.

      5. quercuscommunity Avatar
        quercuscommunity

        I is certainly true in this case. As I steer a course between art and theft, I feel a haibun about beetles and boxes coming on . . . 🙂

      6. Matthew Paul Avatar
        Matthew Paul

        Go for it!

      7. quercuscommunity Avatar
        quercuscommunity

        🙂 As soon as I finish here.

  3. Claire Booker Avatar
    Claire Booker

    Wells looks wonderful. I must get there one day. Thank you for inspiring!

  4. clivebennett796 Avatar
    clivebennett796

    Ah you’re down in my neck of the woods. Although I live in North Wales now I was born in Timsbury and grew up in Bath. I too had a box with a beetle in it a shiny black one from memory. Sounds like you had a pleasant time.

    1. Matthew Paul Avatar
      Matthew Paul

      Thanks, Clive.

      1. clivebennett796 Avatar
        clivebennett796

        In my case the shoulder pain (beetle) turned out to be a Frozen Shoulder which took ages to shrug off although as a child I did literally have a beetle in a box.

Leave a comment